Broken Sword 5 or Point & Click & Dialogues

A few years ago, a game such as Broken Sword 5 – The Serpent’s Curse would have been a major hit for deprived console adventure fans. But these days, after the Telltale games or the superb Life is Strange, and even a renaissance of classic old-fashioned point & click adventures, the question is – can this new instalment of the Broken Sword franchise still impress?

Well, if you’re into this kind of adventure, Broken Sword 5 might just be the game for you! From witty comments and often rather hilarious dialogues to the genre’s typical sometimes rather outlandish puzzles, Broken Sword 5 got it all, just as you might expect. And it’s somewhere in the middle ground between childishly easy and outlandishly crazy – there are rarely any insane combinations to proceed, but sometimes it’s merely “look, there’s something blinking, why don’t you go there?” But sometimes you have to perform several steps over and over again on the path to the correct solution, which can feel tedious.

The major weakness of Broken Sword 5 are the dialogues though; they don’t feel dynamic like in Life is Strange, but thanks to the voice acting, they feel to slow at times. Now don’t get Rabidgames wrong, the quality of the speakers including several accents and nice sarcastic undertones is top notch, but they tend to break the flow of classic point & click in a way that can make you fall asleep at times because you know where the dialogue is getting but it still goes on and on. Sure, you can skip them, but after 10 hours, the same kind of dialogue over and over again becomes tiresome.

Furthermore, as opposed to Life is Strange where you interact with the same people throughout the game so the dialogues can actually show some character development, some characters are there for maybe 20 lines and then they disappear. Forever. So while there is some comedic relief to be had and some important detail to be heard at times, Broken Sword 5 is not as good as its rivals in this aspect.

Unfortunately, this is not the only issue the game is having. On a far broader scale, the game suffers from the ancient formula. While there have been some innovations to the adventure genre in general – some good (more interactivity, branching storylines), some bad (quick time events instead of gameplay) – Broken Sword 5 refuses to go with the flow and stays true to its heritage. Sure, there is some charm in it, but if you play the game for longer than an hour, fatigue sets in eventually. In short bursts however, there is nothing wrong with solving puzzles with a sarcastic undertone at the end of the day.

Rabidgames is puzzled: On the one hand, Broken Sword 5 feels outdated and long-winded in its approach. But on the other hand, it’s the perfect alternative to the other two types of adventures these dates – the narrative walking simulators and the choice based adventures. There is certainly room for old fashioned point & click stories to live, but how big this habitat is remains to be seen.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: